| Year |
Boys Most Valuable Player |
Girls Most Valuable Player |
| 1986 |
Steve Northrup |
* |
| 1987 |
Rick Rokes |
* |
| 1988 |
Andrew Dorfman |
Jenna Rubin |
| 1989 |
Andrew Dorfman |
Jenna Rubin |
| 1990 |
Angelo Cione |
* |
| 1991 |
Mike Fasano |
Katie Hawkesworth |
| 1992 |
Mike Fasano, Matt Schaefer |
Lori Breier, Robyn Greener |
| 1993 |
Jason McCarthy |
Lori Breier |
| 1994 |
Jeff Bates |
Lori Breier |
| 1995 |
Jesse Mones |
Carolyn Schaefer |
| 1996 |
Jesse Mones, Kevin O'Grady, Glenn Schnabel |
Carolyn Schaefer |
| 1997 |
Matt Dreyer |
Antoinette Schoenthaler |
| 1998 |
Nitin Chandra, Ron Oldenborg |
Antoinette Schoenthaler |
| 1999 |
Dan Smith |
Amy Oldenborg |
| 2000 |
Dan Smith |
Dolores Saliba |
| 2001 |
Dan Smith |
Eve Overton |
| 2002 |
Kevin Gordon |
Meghan Molloy |
| 2003 |
Matt Juvet |
Eve Overton |
| 2004 |
Will James |
Lisa Granshaw |
| 2005 |
Mike Quackenbush |
Angela Franco, Lisa Granshaw |
| 2006 |
Jimmy Juvet |
Meghan Hayward, Brianne Musselwhite |
| 2007 |
Dominick Fazzari |
Cristina Sousa |
| 2008 |
Kyle Chiofolo |
Lisa Verzino |
| 2009 |
Stuart Holmes |
Ali Sperduti |
| 2010 |
Pablo Lopez |
Katharine Lynch |
| 2011 |
Andrew Holmes, Chris Rivera |
Katharine Lynch |
